top of page
  • Writer's pictureMike Shu

Deciding to DIY Or Hire A Handyman: A Homeowner's Guide

Updated: Jan 15

A handyman holding his toolbox

Making the choice between handling a task yourself or enlisting the services of a handyman is a personal decision. A thoughtful assessment of your skills, available resources, project requirements, and individual preferences will empower you to make a well-informed choice that resonates with your goals and priorities.

In this blog, we will delve into the considerations that go into deciding whether to tackle a project on your own or bring in a handyman for assistance.

A handyman and another person reviewing a plan inside a partially built house

Evaluating Yourself

Assessing Your DIY Experience and Skills

Past Projects: Reflect on your past experiences with home improvement projects. Have you successfully completed any similar tasks in the past? Did you encounter any significant challenges or setbacks? Examining your past successes and failures can help you gauge your current capabilities and limitations.

Tool Comfort: Identify the tools and techniques you are comfortable using. Are there specific tasks that require unfamiliar tools or skills? Consider the learning curve involved and whether you are willing to invest time and resources in acquiring new knowledge.

Learning Ability: Evaluate your ability to learn new skills and follow instructions. Are you comfortable reading manuals, watching tutorials, and asking for help when needed? Effective learning and adaptation are crucial for successful DIY projects.

Time Commitment

Project Duration: Research and estimate the time required to complete the project yourself. Consider all the steps involved, including planning, acquiring materials, actual work time, and potential delays.

Available Time: Assess your available free time and potential schedule conflicts. Can you dedicate the necessary hours without compromising other obligations? Remember to factor in breaks and unforeseen circumstances.

Time Value: Compare the time investment required for DIY to the value of your time. Could you earn more money during those hours by working instead? Consider the opportunity cost of choosing DIY over hiring a professional.

Budget Constraints

Cost Breakdown: Research the cost of all materials, tools, and permits (if applicable) needed for the project. Look for deals and compare prices from different suppliers.

DIY vs. Handyman: Compare the total DIY cost to potential handyman fees. Include potential expenses for mistakes, delays, and tool purchases in your calculations.

Financial Risk: Evaluate the financial risk of potential mistakes or delays. Could you afford to fix any errors or hire a professional if the project gets out of hand?

Motivation and Enjoyment

Personal Drive: Assess your motivation to complete the project yourself. Are you genuinely interested in learning and doing the work, or are you motivated by external factors like saving money?

Enjoyment Factor: Consider whether you find DIY work enjoyable or stressful. Do you find satisfaction in problem-solving and creating something yourself? Or do you prefer to delegate tasks you don't find particularly rewarding?

Accomplishment vs. Frustration: Weigh the potential satisfaction of accomplishment against the frustration of challenges. Consider your tolerance for setbacks and your ability to manage unexpected difficulties.

Additional Considerations

Safety: Always prioritize safety when evaluating your DIY capabilities. If you are unsure about how to safely complete a task, it's best to seek professional help.

Physical limitations: Be honest about your physical limitations. Don't attempt tasks that require excessive strength, agility, or endurance if you are not physically capable.

Emotional well-being: Consider the potential impact of DIY on your emotional well-being. If you know you get easily frustrated or stressed, weigh the potential benefits of DIY against the potential for negative emotions.

Two individuals evaluating a project together, considering whether to hire a handyman

Evaluating the Project

Project Complexity

Technical Skills: Analyze the technical skills required for the project. Do you possess the necessary knowledge and experience to handle the task? Consider the complexity of techniques, troubleshooting, and potential unforeseen issues.

Precision and Accuracy: Determine the level of precision and accuracy needed for the project. Are there any mistakes that could have serious consequences? If so, consider if your skills are sufficient to ensure a successful outcome.

Safety Risks: Assess potential safety risks involved in the work. Are there any hazardous materials, electrical components, or structural concerns? Prioritize your safety and seek professional help if necessary.

Tools and Equipment

Required Tools: Identify the specific tools and equipment required for the project. Create a detailed list and research their functionality and usage.

Tool Ownership: Determine whether you already own the necessary tools or need to purchase them. Compare the cost of purchasing against the project scope and potential future use.

Rental Options: Consider the cost and availability of renting or borrowing tools. This can be a cost-effective option for projects requiring specialized tools that you may not use frequently.

Permits and Regulations

Research Permits: Research any necessary permits or regulations specific to your project and location. Contact your local building department or relevant authorities for accurate information.

Application Process: Understand the application process for permits, including required documentation, fees, and approval timelines. Ensure you comply fully to avoid delays and fines.

Non-Compliance Risks: Consider the potential consequences of non-compliance with permit regulations. This could include fines, project delays, or even the need to redo work that doesn't meet safety standards.

Availability of Resources

Online Resources: Identify potential online resources that can help you with the project. Online tutorials, manuals, and forums offer valuable information and guidance for DIY projects.

Community Help: Assess the availability of friends, family, or community members who might be able to offer assistance or guidance. Consider their skills and experience and how they could contribute to the project.

Paid Consultants: Evaluate the option of hiring paid consultants like experienced DIYers or professionals for specific aspects of the project. This can be helpful for tasks requiring specialized knowledge or when you need additional confidence in a critical step.

Additional Considerations

Project Scope: Clearly define the scope of the project beforehand. This helps in accurately assessing the required skills, tools, and resources and preventing overambitious plans.

Contingency Plans: Develop contingency plans for potential challenges or unexpected situations. This can help you stay on track and minimize disruption if problems arise.

Project Timeline: Create a realistic timeline for completing the project, considering your available time, potential delays, and external factors.

Budget Flexibility: Allocate a buffer budget to accommodate unexpected costs or changes in the project scope. This ensures you have financial resources to handle unforeseen circumstances.

A woman welcomes a handyman into her home

Hiring a Handyman

Finding a Qualified Handyman

Word-of-Mouth Recommendations: Obtain personal recommendations from friends, family, or neighbors who have recently used a handyman they were happy with. Ask about their experience, satisfaction, and any potential concerns they encountered.

Online Research: Research online reviews and ratings of local handymen on websites like Angie's List, HomeAdvisor, Google My Business, and Yelp. Pay attention to the number and consistency of reviews, focusing on the comments that address relevant skills and experience for your project.

Licensing and Insurance: Check for licensing and insurance coverage of the handyman you are considering. This ensures they are qualified to perform the work and protects you financially in case of accidents or damage.

Professional Associations: Consider contacting professional associations like the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) or the National Association of the Remodeling Industry (NARI) for recommendations of qualified handymen in your area.

Clear Communication and Expectations

Project Goals and Scope: Clearly communicate your project goals, including the desired outcome, specific tasks involved, and your vision for the final result. Be as detailed as possible to avoid misunderstandings and ensure the handyman understands your expectations.

Budget and Timeline: Discuss your budget limitations and desired project timeline openly with the handyman. Be realistic about your timeline and consider potential delays or unforeseen issues that may arise.

Detailed Estimates: Obtain detailed estimates in writing from the handyman, including the breakdown of labor costs, material costs, and any additional fees. This helps ensure transparency and provides a clear picture of the overall project expense.

Communication Plan: Establish a communication plan with the handyman, outlining how you will stay updated on progress and how to address any concerns or questions that may arise during the project.

Formal Contracts and Agreements

Written Contract: Secure a written contract outlining the project scope, price, payment terms, and warranty details. This serves as a legal document that protects both parties and ensures everyone is on the same page.

Change Orders: Include clauses in your contract addressing changes to the project scope, delays, and dispute resolution procedures. This helps manage expectations and provides a clear framework for handling unforeseen circumstances.

Responsibilities and Warranties: Ensure the contract clearly defines the responsibilities of both parties and outlines any warranties offered by the handyman on their work. This provides peace of mind and recourse in case of any issues after project completion.

Monitoring and Oversight

Regular Communication: Maintain regular communication with the handyman throughout the project. Discuss progress, address any concerns promptly, and ensure everything is moving forward as planned.

Periodic Inspections: Conduct periodic inspections of the work completed to ensure it meets your expectations and adheres to agreed-upon standards of quality and craftsmanship.

Final Payment: Finalize payment upon satisfactory completion of the project and after any potential punch list items are addressed. This ensures you are happy with the outcome before releasing full payment.

Additional Tips

Get multiple quotes: Compare quotes from several handymen before making a final decision. This allows you to find the best value for your money and choose a professional who aligns with your budget and project needs.

Ask questions: Don't hesitate to ask questions about the handyman's experience, qualifications, and approach to your specific project. This helps you gain confidence in their ability and ensure they are the right fit for the job.

Check references: Contact references provided by the handyman to verify their work quality, professionalism, and reliability. This can offer valuable insights beyond online reviews and written testimonials.

Trust your gut: Ultimately, trust your gut instinct when choosing a handyman. If you feel unsure or uncomfortable with any aspect of their communication or work ethic, it's best to move on and consider other options.

Decision Matrix

Expanded Decision Matrix: DIY vs. Hiring a Handyman

This matrix helps you compare the advantages and disadvantages of DIY and hiring a handyman for your project.

Project: [Insert Project Name]

Date: [Insert Date]



Hiring a Handyman


Project Complexity (Rate 1-5, 1 being simple, 5 being complex)

[Your Rating]

[Handyman's Experience Rating]

Required Skills and Tools (Rate 1-5, 1 being readily available, 5 being specialized or difficult to acquire)

[Your Skill Rating] + [Tool Availability Rating]

Handyman's Skill Rating

Time Commitment (Rate 1-5, 1 being minimal, 5 being significant)

[Estimated Time Commitment]

[Handyman's Estimated Time]

Budget Constraints (Rate 1-5, 1 being very budget-friendly, 5 being exceeding budget)

[Material Cost] + [Tool Cost] + [Time Cost]

[Handyman's Fee] + [Material Cost]

Enjoyment and Motivation (Rate 1-5, 1 being low, 5 being high)

[Personal Enjoyment Level] + [Motivation Level]


Potential Risks (Rate 1-5, 1 being minimal, 5 being high)

[Risk Assessment]

[Handyman's Insurance Coverage]

Availability of Resources (Rate 1-5, 1 being limited, 5 being readily available)

[Knowledge Access] + [Support Network] + [Tool Availability]

[Handyman's Expertise]

Cost Comparisons (Direct comparison of total costs)

[Total DIY Cost]

[Total Handyman Cost]

Personal Preferences (Rate 1-5, 1 being low importance, 5 being high importance)

[Weighting for Independence and Learning] + [Weighting for Time Efficiency and Quality]



  • Project Complexity: Higher score indicates greater difficulty and potential need for professional expertise.

  • Required Skills and Tools: Higher score indicates the need for specialized skills and tools that might not be readily available or affordable.

  • Time Commitment: Higher score indicates a larger time investment required for DIY.

  • Budget Constraints: Higher score indicates the project may exceed your budget for DIY.

  • Enjoyment and Motivation: Higher score indicates greater personal satisfaction from completing the project yourself.

  • Potential Risks: Higher score indicates a higher risk of errors, injuries, or project failure with DIY.

  • Availability of Resources: Higher score indicates greater access to knowledge, support, and tools for DIY.

  • Cost Comparisons: Direct comparison of total cost for both options.

  • Personal Preferences: Weighting of importance placed on factors like independence, learning, time efficiency, and quality.

Decision Making

  • Analyze the scores for each factor in both columns.

  • Identify factors where DIY offers significant advantages or disadvantages.

  • Evaluate your tolerance for factors that might be challenging for DIY (e.g., complex skills, limited time).

  • Consider your personal preferences and priorities based on the weightings assigned.

  • Ultimately, make an informed decision based on the comprehensive analysis of all factors and your personal circumstances.

Additional Notes

  • This is a customizable framework. You can adjust the factors and scoring system based on the specific requirements of your project.

  • Consider using a weighted scoring system to prioritize factors critical to your decision.

  • Remember, the decision matrix is a tool to help you make an informed choice. It does not guarantee the best outcome.

  • Always seek professional advice for complex projects or when unsure about your abilities.

By using the expanded decision matrix and carefully evaluating your project and personal preferences, you can choose the approach that best suits your needs and ensures a successful completion of your project.

A handyman gives a thumbs up with a tool in hand


Deciding between DIY and hiring a handyman for home improvements hinges on personal factors like your skills, project needs, and circumstances. Use tools like the decision matrix to assess these aspects for a confident choice. Understanding your abilities and priorities guides you to the right decision for successful home improvement outcomes.

5 views0 comments


bottom of page